The above flag is the flag for New Orleans, also nicknamed Crescent City.
Dinner the other evening came by way of Nigella Express (Nigella Lawson), in however a slightly adapted way. Please note here that the recipes following are my adapted versions and not Nigella’s original.
We had buttermilk chicken with New Orleans coleslaw which I served with some crispy potato wedges.

I have to admit I was dubious about the coleslaw, I’m not a massive fan of coleslaw anyway but this just didn’t seem to fit a regular recipe pattern – maple syrup, vinegar, buttermilk (which I swapped to sour cream), this didn’t seem at all right; but hey, I was very nicely surprised as the coleslaw was tangy but slightly sweet, light but creamy and not at all cloying or sickly which I sometimes find it to be. Shockingly I went back for second helpings and my mum did too, now that is saying something as she is the worlds biggest hater of mayonnaise LOL
I got some wary glances when the pecans were found but everyone loved them, they added a vibrant, sweet, buttery crunch and they really would be sorely missed if they got left from the dish.
The Pecan (Carya illinoinensis or illinoensis) is a species of hickory, native to south-central North America.

The chicken was beautifully tender, partly due to the quality of the chicken and partly due to the use of buttermilk in the marinade. Buttermilk is a great tenderiser and this way of marinading must be tried by all at least once, well, I say at least once but once you try it you will not turn back. The buttermilk doesn’t lend a creaminess to the chicken at all and it doesn’t impart a flavour, just a sweet tenderness.
The crushed peppercorns give it a kick here and there when you bite into it, so if you don’t like that, I would just use freshly ground black pepper instead. This rather gentle warming heat when combining with (my addition of) the old bay seasoning the flavour is superb. Bay seasoning containscelery seed, bay leaf, mustard seed, both black and red pepper, cinnamon, and ginger, making it an intensely flavoured blend. Typically it is used most with seafood dishes but trust me it works well with chicken too
Whilst this was fabulously good hot for dinner it also made for an interesting and flavoursome cold lunch the following day. The coleslaw kept well in a sealed container for three days, I’m sure you’ll have eaten it all by then anyway but I wouldn’t risk leaving it any longer.
Of course to complete the American diner feeling I had to make sure a glass of ice cold Coca Cola was on hand too
Buttermilk Bay Chicken
- 6 chicken thights (deboned)
- 500ml buttermilk
- 60ml vegetable oil, plus extra for drizzling
- 2 garlic cloves, peeled and lightly crushed
- 1 tablespoon crushed peppercorns
- 1 tablespoon sea salt
- 2 teaspoons bay seasoning
- 1 tablespoon maple syrup
- Place the chicken pieces into a large plastic freezer bag and add the buttermilk and vegetable oil.
- Add the lightly crushed garlic cloves to the bag along with the crushed peppercorns and salt.
- Sprinkle in the bay seasoning and add the maple syrup, then gently squeeze the bag to mix the marinade ingredients together and coat the chicken.
- Seal the bag and leave the chicken to marinate in the fridge, ideally overnight, or out of the fridge for at least 30 minutes and up to two hours.
- Preheat the oven to 220C or the equivalent.
- Take the chicken pieces out of the bag, shaking off the excess marinade, and arrange them in a roasting tin lined with foil
- Drizzle over a little oil, then transfer to the oven and roast for about 30 minutes, or until golden-brown and completely cooked through.
New Orleans Coleslaw
- 1 spring green cabbage
- 2 carrots
- 4 spring onions
- 1 red pepper
- 300ml mayonnaise
- 4 tablespoons sour cream
- 2 tablespoons maple syrup
- 2 teaspoons apple cider vinegar
- Salt and freshly ground black pepper
- 50g pecans, roughly chopped
- Trim and shred the cabbage; you can do this either by hand or with a food processor.
- Peel and grate the carrots, and finely slice the pepper and spring onions.
- Whisk together the mayonnaise, sour cream, maple syrup and vinegar and coat the shredded vegetables with this dressing.
- Season with salt and pepper and toss with the chopped nuts, just before serving.















{ 37 comments… read them below or add one }
I have to bookmark this recipes….
Sounds interesting, The buttermilk may not suit me though. Maybe sometime when I have guests, mind you that won’t be until I am well on my feet again.
Looks great George. I love the look of that coleslaw. It won’t be long until I make it. I have very affectionate memories of New Orleans.
I just popped onto tastespotting for the first time in months and I just knew that photo was yours as soon as I saw it. Looks amazing George. xxx
I love buttermilk as a marinade/brine for chicken. I make my fried chicken using that step as a starting point, too.
I’m not sure that slaw would be first choice, though. I really like vinaigrette style coleslaws best.
Nice pictures!
Oh my, I am so tempted to make the chicken and the slaw. Never seen a slaw with maple syrup. That must be so delicious.
This looks like just the type of thing I would love to cook. I adore buttermilk chicken. Don’t know why I don’t have it more. And I’m a fool for coleslaw. Love it. This looks delicious!
I’ve missed so much around here! This chicken looks gorgeous and I love the Nigella Express book, I just finished re-reading it just for the pictures
This blog rocks! I’m glad I found your blog. Thanks,
The recipe sounds wonderful, and your images are divine. Makes my mouth water just looking at them.
I live in Central Texas (near three great BBQ joints, if you like BBQ), and used to go to New Orleans several times a year when I lived on the Texas/Louisianna border. NOLA is a great city, despite the tragedy of Hurricane Katrina. Do yourself the favor and visit sometime.
Like you, I am not a fan of overly sweet slaw, but this one looks lovely.
I would appreciate ounces and Farenheit temperatures instead of ml and C.
Thank you so much for your lovely comment Cecilia. I’m pretty new to the photography side of all this so your comment means a lot
Do give the slaw a go if you have chance it really is lovely.
I’d lovely to visit New Orleans some day.
sounds great! I love using buttermilk with my chicken, and never understood the reasoning why so many recipes called for it, but now I do! Thanks!
Thanks Peggy for commenting and I’m glad I could help
I am baffled why the slaw is called New Orleans Coleslaw for I have never seen anything like it in New Orleans, although our Carrot Salad is remotely similar, being shredded carrots with raisins and a mayonnaise-sour cream dressing. But Maple Syrup is rarely used here, it would be Steen’s Sugarcane Syrup or plain white sugar and cane or wine vinegar instead of apple cider vinegar. Chopped toasted pecans would certainly be welcome.
Hi, I’m going to give this a try this week. I’m curious why you suggest doing the “quick” buttermilk marinate out of the fridge. I always thought that the fridge helped speed up the marinating….but if i am mistaken I would love to be better informed.
Just found you via Saveur. What a beautiful recipe and so well presented too. I must try this
Hi there. I live in New Zealand where “bay seasoning” isn’t readily available. Any suggestions as to how I can make it myself? I’m assuming it includes bay leaf….thanks.
Thanks very much, I’ll give them a try. I’ve got it in the fridge marinating using Nigella’s recipe, which uses rosemary instead of the bay seasoning, but I’ll try that next time.
What a lovely recipe, I’ll try it. Found you via Saveur.
Thanks Del.
I hope you enjoy them Elra, do please let me know
Hi Grannymar. Yogurt could be used instead of the buttermilk if that suits you better. I didn’t realise you were ‘offit’, do hope you’re better soon
Thanks Brenda
I hope you enjoy the coleslaw. I remember you saying you’d been to New Orleans, it is a place (amongst many others) I would love to go too.
Thank you so much Vicky
Hi Dana! Buttermilk is so good for marinading ready for fried chicken isn’t it – it helps both tenderise the chicken and crisp up the crumb on frying, just perfect.
This slaw has to be tried to be believed I think – I’m no fan of creamy coleslaw but this really tickled my tastebuds. I love the Asian style ‘coleslaw’ salads of finely chopped vegetables & salad in hot, sweet, salty, sour light dressings most though.
Glad you like the photos too
Don’t just be tempted Helene, do make it
The slaw is gorgeous, lovely and sweet and rounded with the syrup and nuts.
Thanks Julia. It’s not the type of food I cook very often either but I just happened to have a pack of chicken thighs and a cabbage to use up and stumbled upon this idea by having an inspiring read of Nigella Express; I love how ideas can just spring up like that
Thank you Lucy. The photography in Nigella Express is good but right now I’m really enjoying David Loftus’ work.
Thank you Bill
Glad you like it here.
David I don’t work in Farenheit or ounces (nor do I feel the need to convert here in my recipes) but I do have a conversion chart that you can use, just click the conversions link at the top of the page. Hope that helps some.
Hi, thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment
I really like the idea of the Carrot Salad and am intrigued by Steen’s Sugarcane Syrup (I’ve never seen that here).
I used apple cider vinegar as I had it on hand but I’m sure plain white wine vinegar would work fine.
As for the name, well Nigella says this in Nigella Express “I can’t remember why I call it my New Orleans Coleslaw now (I’ve been making it, or a version of it, for so long), but I think it has something to do with all the wonderful pecan trees I saw when I was there.” Hope that helps.
Hi Ellen
The option to do a quick marinade is simply because the recipe came from a book based around meals that could be prepped and cooked really quickly, ideal for midweek meals etc and Nigella said that if you were organised you’d have the chicken in the fridge before heading out to work, but if you forgot you could get it done quickly in the evening … personally I find a longer marinade better
Thank you very much for stopping by and leaving such a lovely comment Lauren. I do hope you’ll enjoy the recipes.
Hi Karen, thank you for visiting my blog. I’ll have a hunt through some books to see if I can find a ‘home made’ Bay seasoning. Be right back.
Hi Karen I’ve found a couple of links to recipes that may help, I haven’t tried them though so can’t vouch for how good they are:
http://busycooks.about.com/od/homemademixes/r/oldbaymix.htm
http://etherwork.net/blog/?p=203
http://www.recipezaar.com/Old-Bay-Seasoning-2-15562
Hope they help.
Enjoy Nigella’s recipe, it’s very good. Do let me know how you get on with the home made Bay Seasoning next time please.
{ 2 trackbacks }